Harmful outputPI-0059
Lawsuit alleges ChatGPT's medical advice delayed care for a near-fatal pulmonary embolism
A 55-year-old former pastor from Florida alleges GPT-4o told him over months that his recurring dizzy spells were not yet serious and discouraged him from seeking care. He suffered a pulmonary embolism in July 2025 that he says nearly killed him, and sued OpenAI in San Francisco.
Harm: Severe harm, allegedControl level 1, No rule broken, alleged
Alleged in court · Not counted: AI role uncorroboratedEffect on the index
Alleged. The AI system's part in the harm is not corroborated, so it is shown at the level claimed and adds nothing to the index. This does not dispute that the harm itself occurred.
Sources
How we know
5 sources · unverified claim. Links go to the original publishers; the summary above is in our own words.
- primaryPastor sues after OpenAI's ChatGPT allegedly discouraged him from seeking medical care during life-threatening blood clotsTech Justice Law Project · July 22, 2026techjusticelaw.org/press-releases/pastor-sues-after-openai-ai-chatgpt-allegedly…
- courtComplaint, Winters v. OpenAI, Inc. (Cal. Super. Ct., San Francisco)Tech Justice Law / Social Media Victims Law Center (via Bloomberg Law) · July 21, 2026aboutblaw.com/bmlJ
- newsPastor Sues OpenAI After ChatGPT Dissuaded Seeking Medical CareBloomberg Law · July 22, 2026news.bloomberglaw.com/litigation/pastor-sues-openai-after-chatgpt-dissuaded-see…
- newsMan sues OpenAI over dangerous medical advice from ChatGPTCourthouse News Service · July 22, 2026courthousenews.com/articles/man-sues-openai-over-dangerous-medical-advice-from…
- newsChatGPT led to a man's near-fatal health crisis, lawsuit claimsBoston.com · July 22, 2026boston.com/news/technology/2026/07/22/chatgpt-led-to-a-mans-near-fatal-health-c…
Why this rating
Severe harm, alleged; control failure level 1
Two assessments. Documented harm sets the reading; a level 4 or 5 control failure on the same record makes that harm count as more than one record. Control alone sets only a floor.
Observed harm
Severe harm, allegedLife-threatening illness requiring hospital care, as alleged.
Health & safety: 1 to 9 deaths, or serious harm to health (hospitalization).
The harm scale
- 1 Negligible Inconvenience, easily remedied.
- 2 Minor Limited, recoverable harm.
- 3 Moderate Material harm needing significant effort to remedy.
- 4 Severe Severe harm to health, rights, property or essential services.
- 5 Catastrophic Society-scale harm or disruption beyond a community's capacity to cope.
Control assessment
No rule broken, allegedFlawed medical advice; no rule-break or permission breach established.
No rule was broken, so it cannot set the control floor.
The control scale
- 1 Negligible Behaved as instructed. The problem was an ordinary error or a flawed output, with no rule broken.
- 2 Minor Broke an explicit instruction or rule, or gamed its goal, while staying inside its permissions and environment: for example, reward hacking, misreporting results, or following injected instructions within its permissions.
- 3 Moderate Acted outside the permissions it was given, deceived its overseers about its own actions, or tampered with oversight tools (logs, monitors, shutdown). Stopped by normal controls within an hour.
- 4 Severe Reached systems outside its permitted environment, or acquired money, compute or accounts without authorization. The type and mechanism say how.
- 5 Catastrophic The developer or operator lost control: the system copied its weights outside their control, replicated itself, or resisted being stopped for 24 hours or more.
Rating rationale
The patient's complaint (signed July 21, 2026) alleges that GPT-4o discouraged him over months from seeking care before a pulmonary embolism on July 13, 2025. The complaint and its chat excerpts were read; they are allegations, not findings, and the AI's causal role remains uncorroborated. Claimed health harm contributes nothing. Harm and control levels describe the claim, not a finding of AI causation.
Effect on the index
It does not count toward the July 27 reading
The reading for the week to July 27, 2026, with this record and without it. Harms count in full for two weeks after they are reported, then one level less every two weeks.
Not counted: AI role uncorroborated. 3 other records behind the reading for that week.
The arithmetic
| Step | With it | Without |
|---|---|---|
| Counts toward the index?documented, external, eligible evidence | No | — |
| Worst documented harm, ksets the band | 3 Moderate | 3 Moderate |
| Harms at that level, nposition in the band | 1 | 1 |
| Highest control level breachedsets the reading only when no harm counts | — (none breached) | — (none breached) |
| Readingrounded down | 45 Moderate harm | 45 Moderate harm |
Inside the window of 4 weekly readings
| Week to | Reading | Band |
|---|---|---|
| July 27, 2026 | 45 | Moderate harm |
| Aug. 3, 2026 | 31 | Minor harm |
| Aug. 10, 2026 | 31 | Minor harm |
| Aug. 17, 2026 | 16 | Negligible harm |
Revisions
What we changed
1 logged. Every change to a rating is logged here, with the reason.
- v1Oct. 7, 2026
First published.
Cite and share
Use this record
Citation
Paperclip Index. “Lawsuit alleges ChatGPT's medical advice delayed care for a near-fatal pulmonary embolism.” Record PI-0059. Reported July 22, 2026; updated Oct. 7, 2026. Rated under methodology v1.1. https://paperclipindex.com/incident/PI-0059